The challenging part then ends up being the handoff from one chauffeur to the other. The picked frequency range for this handoff is called crossover, however its not a best cutoff.Rather, theres a gradual transition from one chauffeur to the other, and in an excellent speaker, you want this transition to be as smooth as possible. Common crossovers for bookshelf speakers with one woofer and one tweeter are centered someplace in the greater midrange, between 1 and 4 kHz.Things are then even more made complex by the fact that tweeters and woofers do not simply radiate noise in a single instructions. Its something to smooth the crossover region in the forward instructions– the speakers on-axis action. Its a lot more difficult to smooth it out in all instructions, as each driver will radiate sound differently depending upon the frequency. Rarely does a speaker get it perfect.This relationship in between a speakers direct and off-axis sound is called a speakers directivity. Having smooth directivity assists develop a strong soundstage and preserve even tonality when speakers are put in a space. Which, you know, is the majority of them.Directivity matters since we do not just hear noise in a line of sight from the speakers to our ears; the sound that shows off our walls makes a substantial affective contribution. So in the finest speakers– those with the most sensible soundstage and most even tonality– the shown sound will be comparable in character to the direct sound.Its also worth noting that while horizontal directivity impacts both soundstage and tonality, vertical directivity primarily affects tonality. (Our ears are on the sides of our heads, after all, not on our scalp and chin. Thank god.) As such, many speakers will optimize for horizontal directivity while compromising on the vertical; even the very best speakers hardly ever carry out perfectly on both fronts.What does great directivity look like?A picture deserves a thousand words, so the frequency response chart listed below shows what a theoretical speaker with good directivity may look like at 0º (the direct noise) and 60º off-axis horizontally (what might be reflecting off your walls). The sound gets quieter off-axis and tilts down a bit, but you can see the line preserves the exact same general shape (I drew these curves with my touchscreen so no genuine speaker really looks quite this smooth). In a real terrific speaker like the Neumann KH80 (which does have a waveguide), you can see how for the many part, the reaction modifications gradually as you move even more off-axis: How the Neumann KH80s action changes at 15º intervals off-axisIn an excellent speaker like this, you cant truly see where the crossover remains in the horizontal off-axis information– theres no discontinuity in between the woofer and tweeter.Now, lets look at our theoretical speaker once again, but this time imagine it has bad horizontal directivity:( You dont generally see speakers rather this bad nowadays, but I have seen them.) Although it maintains a fairly linear direct noise, you can see a large dip at the crossover. This indicates the noise that shows off your walls will be different to the direct noise. Your poor brain gets confused, and the speaker just doesnt sound as good as it could. The soundstage will be fuzzier, and theres a likelihood the speaker will sound recessed in the midrange.Heres one more scenario. What happens if the direct sound is awful, however the directivity is still good? It might look something like this: This speaker will clearly have actually jeopardized tonality due to the big dips in its action, however, the relationship between the off-axis and on-axis curve is nonetheless still smooth.In practice, this would likely cause a speaker with unequal tonality however an excellent soundstage. For factors beyond the scope of this piece, the good idea about these speakers is that you may effectively be able to use EQ to them to fix their tonality.In contrast, you cant do much to repair a speaker with bad directivity. No amount of EQ will assist, so your best choice would be to treat your walls and reduce the reflections altogether.Reflections not matching the direct sound is the acoustic equivalent of taking a bite into a delicious pizza only to be consulted with a cool aftertaste. No matter how excellent that initial bite is, its going to sour the overall experience.So how does a waveguide aid develop smooth directivity?This is where the guide part can be found in– the waveguides shape will significantly form the tweeters directivity.Without getting too technical, a great waveguide (not a minor matter!) is carefully created to make the tweeters directivity match the woofer around the chosen crossover. This decreases any abnormalities both on and off-axis, although for the most part it can not absolutely conserve the vertical response.The Dutch and Dutch 8cs waveguide is carefully created for some of the very best directivity efficiency I have seen.A waveguide can also permit you to utilize a lower crossover for the tweeter than you may be able to otherwise. This can assist smooth the transition too, as when a woofer is made to play really high frequencies, it has a tendency to beam, or radiate sound more highly in the forward instructions, while tweeters tend to be omnidirectional at the bottom of their range.Is that all a waveguide does– smoothing over the crossover?Aside from just smoothing out the crossover area, a waveguide can be utilized to form the total directivity of a speaker to the designers intent.It can be utilized to narrow or expand directivity in different frequency regions, which will affect both the soundstage and tonality. Some waveguides are likewise developed to have broader horizontal directivity and narrower vertical directivity, as is the case with the abovementioned Neumann KH80.A waveguide can likewise be designed to act as a horn, which, like a trumpet horn, can assist enhance the sound source. Some makers simply choose to stick to the term horn. Especially if, you understand, the waveguide appears like a horn. Its exact residential or commercial properties depend exactly on its shape and the user interface with the driver.So are speakers with waveguides constantly better?Waveguides arent essential for great directivity efficiency. They are an indispensable tool for a speaker designer, and in my experience speakers with waveguides are most likely to have excellent directivity than those that do not. Definitely, if the waveguide is properly designed and well-implemented, it is seldom a bad thing.The Focal Chora 806 only has the subtlest of waveguides; many of the directivity control remains in the style of the tweeter itself.That said, waveguides typically narrow directivity in the frequency range largely responsible for the perception of soundstage width. This generally implies a more determine soundstage, but may come at the expense of a sense of width, or expansiveness.Narrower directivity isnt great or inherently bad, and research into the subject suggests its mainly a matter of personal choice and how the speaker engages with a specific space. In spite of all the appreciation Ive showered on making use of waveguides, Im typically going to compromise some precision for a larger soundstage. Your mileage may vary, and this will depend on the particular recording youre listening to as well.And obviously, the waveguides application matters. Some waveguides are implied to supply an enormous amount of directivity control, while others are only meant to help refine the response a little.Ive seen speakers with waveguides that have poor directivity, and Ive seen speakers with no or very little waveguides that show outstanding performance. You can accomplish smooth directivity in other methods, such as by utilizing an intermediary midrange chauffeur that is smaller sized than the bass woofer but bigger than the tweeter.At the end of the day, just the information and mindful listening can tell you whether the waveguide is doing its job. While I always wish speaker business would be more open about sharing their speaker measurements, the use of a waveguide at least suggests the engineers were attempting to optimize directivity. Thats pretty much constantly a good thing.Did you know we have a newsletter all about consumer tech? Its called Plugged In–.
and you can subscribe to it right here.
If youre in the marketplace for a new set of hi-fi speakers or studio displays, you might have discovered the term waveguide before. You mayve seen a picture or illustration in marketing products pointing to a fancy trim ring or horn-looking-thing around a speakers tweeter, as in the header image above. Often a waveguide is even directly incorporated into the speakers cabinet design itself.This is more than simply a visual frivolity. You mightve utilized your big brain to speculate that a waveguide has something to do with assisting the noise waves. If so, congratulations– youre a smarty pants. Why, exactly, do you want to direct sound waves?Why would waveguides assist waves?In general, a speaker designer will use a waveguide to improve the integration between the different drivers on a speaker– to assist the sound of a tweeter better match the noise of a woofer.As youve most likely discovered– but possibly never ever thought much about– tweeters and woofers are generally different sizes (and shapes and products). Thats because different designs are better fit to dealing with specific frequency ranges, with the tweeter nearly constantly being smaller than the woofer.
Why, exactly, do you desire to assist sound waves?Why would waveguides assist waves?In general, a speaker designer will utilize a waveguide to enhance the integration in between the different motorists on a speaker– to help the sound of a tweeter better match the noise of a woofer.As youve most likely observed– however maybe never ever believed much about– tweeters and woofers are typically various sizes (and shapes and materials). Many speakers will optimize for horizontal directivity while compromising on the vertical; even the finest speakers rarely perform completely on both fronts.What does great directivity appearance like?An image is worth a thousand words, so the frequency response chart listed below shows what a theoretical speaker with excellent directivity might look like at 0º (the direct sound) and 60º off-axis horizontally (what may be reflecting off your walls). They are an indispensable tool for a speaker designer, and in my experience speakers with waveguides are more most likely to have good directivity than those that dont. Some waveguides are indicated to provide a huge amount of directivity control, while others are just meant to assist fine-tune the action a little.Ive seen speakers with waveguides that have poor directivity, and Ive seen speakers with no or minimal waveguides that show outstanding efficiency. While I always want speaker business would be more open about sharing their speaker measurements, the usage of a waveguide at least suggests the engineers were attempting to optimize directivity.